California Court of Appeal July 24, 1990, B045830 (County of Los Angeles v. Superior Court)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-07-1990

Opinion

GOERTZEN, J.

Petitioner/defendant County of Los Angeles (the County) moved for a protective order and to disqualify the attorney of plaintiff/real party in interest Alfredo Ruiz Hernandez (plaintiff)- The County sought to prevent plaintiff from designating the County’s formerly designated expert witness as his expert witness and to remove plaintiff’s counsel. Upon denial of its motion and award of $750 in attorney fees/costs to plaintiff, the County petitioned this court for extraordinary relief, which we granted. The issue we are asked to resolve is: May a party withdraw its designation of an expert trial witness, who is not yet deposed and who remains as that party’s consultant, and thereby preclude the deposition of that expert as well as his or her retention as an expert in the action by adverse parties? For the reasons discussed below, we answer affirmatively.

Record

On March 6, 1985, plaintiff filed a complaint for medical malpractice against the County and others.

1

The County answered on May 3, 1985, and on July 14, 1989, served its designation of expert witnesses. (Code Civ. Proc., § 2034.)

2

Among the experts designated was M. Anthony Verity, M.D., a board certified pathologist.

*651

On July 17, 1989, plaintiff filed his designation of expert witnesses and did not designate a pathologist to testify at trial.

After the original deposition date was continued, on July 27, 1989, plaintiff served notice of Dr. Verity’s deposition for August 8, 1989.

On August 1, the County served its amendment to designation of expert witnesses, withdrawing Dr. Verity as an expert and reserving its right to designate an expert in the same area of expertise of pathology and neuropathology.

3

On August 8, 1989, plaintiff served an augmentation of expert witness list, stating his intention to call Dr. Verity as an expert witness at trial.

Subsequently, both parties filed several motions.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.