Indiana Supreme Court December 12, 1990, 37S04-9012-CV-774 (Paramo v. Edwards)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-12-1990

DICKSON, Justice.

This case seeks clarification of the applicability of the doctrine of equitable estop-pel to avoid a statute of limitations defense. We grant transfer to address the issue.

The plaintiffs-appellants Jesus Paramo and his wife Santa Paramo allege that they sustained injuries in a motor vehicle accident on September 6, 1983. Their resulting claims were asserted in an action not filed until December 27, 1985. The defendants Roger D. Edwards, Artim Transportation System, Inc., and Steel and Machinery

*597

Transport Co., Inc., filed a motion to dismiss affirmatively asserting the two-year statute of limitations, Ind.Code § 34-1-2-2. The plaintiffs responded by alleging that the conduct of the defendants’ insurer should estop defendants from asserting the defense.

In support of their claim of equitable estoppel to oppose summary judgment, the Paramos submitted affidavits of their attorneys, Stephen B. Cohen and Brian L. Burchett, who began representing the plaintiffs in this matter in September, 1984. Cohen’s affidavit contains the following relevant information:

3. On or about July 23, 1985, he [Cohen] had a telephone conversation with one of the claims adjusters of American Interinsurance Exchange handling the file. He told the adjuster that they were having difficulty in obtaining information necessary to substantiate plaintiffs’ claims, and that he thought it would be unwise to file suit and incur litigation expenses on a claim that might have either great value or small value depending upon the information obtained.

4. He and the adjuster agreed that no lawsuit would be required as long as the parties remained in contact with one another and due diligence was used to obtain the information necessary to substantiate plaintiffs’ claims and indicate their value.

5. During the conversation he and the adjuster agreed not to file suit until all efforts at settlement had been exhausted.

Record at 69.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.