Indiana Court of Appeals December 12, 1990, 82A01-9005-CV-213 (Scales v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-12-1990

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

RATLIFF, Chief Judge.

John Burley Scales, Betty DeWitt Scales, Mark S. Krantz, and Jo Ann Krantz (collectively “Landowners”) appeal the Vander-burgh Superior Court’s dismissal of their complaint for declaratory judgment. We affirm.

FACTS

1

Landowners own real estate located in Warrick County, Indiana, a portion of which lies over a vein of coal. Since they purchased the property in 1986, Landowners have excavated certain minerals

*665

from the land for commercial use and sale. The excavation work has been contracted out to Krantz Brothers Construction Corporation (KB) of which Mark S. Krantz is secretary-treasurer.

On April 6, 1989, the Indiana Department of Natural Resources, Division of Reclamation (DNR) issued a Cessation Order (CO) to KB, based on its contention that KB’s removal of minerals from Landowners’ real estate constituted “surface coal mining operations” without a permit, as required under the Indiana Surface Coal Mining and Reclamation Act (ISCMRA).

2

The CO required KB to cease all surface coal mining on areas overlying the coal on Landowners’ real estate. KB contested the issuance of the CO, and requested a formal hearing claiming: (1) the operation was not a coal mining operation and thus the CO was improper, and (2) if the Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) were to determine the operation was subject to DNR regulation, then KB was entitled to an exemption to the permitting process under IND.CODE § 13-4.1-1-3(12)(A), which provides an exemption to the permitting process for operations where the coal does not exceed 16%% of the tonnage of minerals removed for purposes of commercial use or sale.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.