Michigan Court of Appeals November 20, 1990, Docket 118878, 118879 (Noyd v. Claxton, Morgan, Flockhart & VanLiere)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-11-1990

Per Curiam.

This is a consolidated appeal as of right from a Kent Circuit Court order granting summary disposition to defendant NBD Business Finance, Inc., on plaintiffs’ claim that nbd violated the Michigan Uniform Securities Act (musa), MCL 451.501

et seq.;

MSA 19.776(101)

et seq.

Plaintiffs also appeal the circuit court’s grant of partial summary disposition for defendants Claxton, Morgan, Flockhart & VanLiere, Certified Public Accountants (Claxton, Morgan), and individual defendants Gregory Claxton and Donald Morgan, on plaintiffs’ musa claim against those defendants. In

*335

addition, plaintiffs appeal the circuit court’s denial of their motion for leave to file a second amended complaint, which would have added a fraud claim against defendant Claxton, Morgan. We affirm.

In January of 1985, defendant nbd loaned Kent-Holland Industries, Incorporated (khi), operating funds and took back a security interest in khi’s accounts receivable, assets and inventory. Khi had been formed sometime prior to 1985 as a result of a merger of two companies during Chapter xi reorganization proceedings in federal bankruptcy court. By May of 1985, khi no longer complied with nbd’s borrowing formula and nbd apparently refused to lend khi any more money. In June of 1985, plaintiffs and nbd entered into the first of three "loan participation agreements” whereby plaintiffs loaned money to khi through nbd. The agreement was set up after negotiations between nbd, Claxton, Morgan, which was khi’s accounting firm, and khi’s attorneys.

Under the agreements, plaintiffs received payments of 5.5 percent above the prime interest rate on any outstanding loans to khi. Plaintiffs were to be repaid the loan principal only after nbd was paid in full for nbd’s outstanding loans to khi. If nbd realized upon the security interest it held in khi, plaintiffs would also be able to realize the collateral under nbd’s security interest, but, again, only after nbd’s loan was satisfied.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.