Court of Appeals of Wisconsin September 27, 1990, 89-0683 (Advance Concrete Form, Inc. v. Accuform, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-09-1990

SUNDBY, J.

Advance Concrete Form, Inc., a minority shareholder in Accuform, Inc., appeals from a judgment dismissing its complaint to enforce its rights under sec. 180.43, Stats. Advance contends that Accuform's year-end financial statements provided to Advance were not in reasonable detail as required by sec. 180.43(1). It also claims that there is no credible evidence supporting the circuit court's finding that Advance did not have a proper purpose under sec. 180.43(2) to examine and extract from Accuform's books and records. Finally, Advance argues that dismissing its complaint was too drastic and that the circuit court should have considered alternatives which would protect Accuform from Advance's possible improper use of information obtained from examination of Accuform's books and records.

*338

We hold that the circuit court correctly concluded that Accuform's annual financial statements were in reasonable detail and satisfied the requirements of sec. 180.43(1), Stats., and that Advance did not have a proper purpose under sec. 180.43(2) to examine and extract from Accuform's books and records. We reject Advance's argument that the circuit court should have considered less drastic alternatives to dismissing Advance's complaint. We therefore affirm.

BACKGROUND

Advance and Accuform are competitors in manufacturing and selling concrete forms used in the construction of building foundations. Advance hired away an Accuform employee and purchased his ten percent of Accuform's stock.

As a shareholder, Advance made written demands of Accuform under sec. 180.43(2), Stats., to examine and extract from Accuform's books and records. Advance's written demands stated that it wished to examine the books and records to value its investment in Accuform's stock and to evaluate the company's previous year's performance.

Accuform's annual financial statements were "compiled" statements.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.