District Court, District of Columbia February 8, 1990, Crim. 88-0080-01 (HHG) (United States v. Poindexter)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-02-1990

*164

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

HAROLD H. GREENE, District Judge.

On February 7, 1990, in response to the Court’s Order of the same date, counsel for President Reagan answered in the affirmative the Court’s question whether the former President’s filing of February 5, 1990 was “intended to constitute a formal claim by the President of executive privilege .... ” That answer lays to rest the question whether the former President has asserted the doctrine of executive privilege in relation to the defense demand for certain diary entries. Several consequences ensue from the making of the executive privilege claim. One of these, which relates to certain

ex parte

filings by the defendant, is discussed below.

In its December 21, 1989 Opinion, the Court rejected requests by President Reagan and the Department of Justice for

ex parte

filings by the defendant regarding his defenses and his need for documents from the former President. The Court allowed such filings to be made

ex parte

because, in view of the presumption of innocence, a criminal defendant is not required, absent special and countervailing circumstances, to reveal his defenses and the theories underlying them in advance of his presentation of evidence at the trial. However, as the Court stated in the December 21, 1989 Opinion, and again on January 30, 1990, the protection of the prerogatives of the Presidency presents such a special and countervailing circumstance. Accordingly, once these prerogatives have been formally advanced in court by way of a claim of executive privilege, the President is entitled to the

ex parte

filings. Access to these filings will, of course, assist in enabling the President to make his presentation to the Court regarding the balance to be struck between the defendant’s need for the Presidential documents and the legitimate prerogatives of the Presidency.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.