Supreme Court of Pennsylvania July 9, 1990, 01001 and 01195 (Lowenschuss v. Lowenschuss)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-07-1990

BECK, Judge:

This case requires us to decide the circumstances under which a spouse may be estopped from asserting the invalidity of the other spouse’s prior foreign divorce. Appellant wife argues that husband is estopped from asserting the invalidity of her 1964 Alabama divorce. We agree.

The parties entered a ceremonial marriage in 1965. At the time of the marriage husband, an experienced attorney, knew that wife had obtained an Alabama divorce from her previous spouse even though she had never lived there. For at least nine and possibly for as long as seventeen years the parties cohabited as man and wife. They had four children. In 1974, husband contends he first became fully aware of the invalidity of wife’s Alabama divorce. In 1981, wife instituted an action in divorce. Husband defended the action on the ground that no valid marriage between the parties exists because of the invalidity of wife’s prior divorce. The trial court agreed and dismissed the action.

We begin our analysis with a detailed recitation of the facts as they emerge from the voluminous record in this action. In 1959, appellant Beverly Lowenschuss (“wife”) married Elliot Bender. The marriage was not successful. In June 1964, wife travelled to Alabama to procure a divorce from Mr. Bender. She did so with Mr. Bender’s consent. Alabama was chosen as the forum for the divorce pursuant to advice from wife’s then attorney, Mr. Edelstein, who put her in touch with an Alabama attorney. Wife spent at most two days in Alabama and does not dispute the fact that she has never been a bona fide resident of Alabama. Wife concedes that she misrepresented that she was a resident of that state in the documents she filed to procure the divorce. The day after wife returned from

*534

Alabama, the Circuit Court of Winston County, Alabama entered a divorce decree divorcing her from Elliot Bender.

The trial court made no specific finding as to what wife knew concerning the validity of her divorce from Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.