Court of Appeals of Maryland September 26, 1990, 53, September Term, 1988 (Morris v. Weddington)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-09-1990

COLE, Judge.

In this case we are asked to determine whether a witness’s inadvertent statement that the defendant in a personal injury case did not have automobile insurance coverage is sufficient grounds for a mistrial and whether the trial court later acted within its discretion in denying a motion for a new trial.

The facts which gave rise to this controversy are neither complicated nor in dispute. What occurred at trial is somewhat complicated, however, and a proper understanding of those events is essential to the resolution of the issues. Therefore, the pertinent portions of the trial will be set forth in some detail.

Keith Morris, a child of three, was injured when he was struck by a van driven by Respondent, William H. Wedding-ton, Jr. Keith sustained a fracture of his left leg which required surgery and subsequent treatment including a total of twelve weeks in a cast. Keith’s mother, Petitioner Brenda Morris, brought suit in the Circuit Court for Prince George’s County individually and as mother and next friend of Keith for the injuries sustained by Keith and expenses

*676

incurred by her on his behalf.

1

At trial, Petitioner’s primary witness, Anthony Schaefer, was cross-examined regarding his relationship with Weddington. The following exchange took place:

Q. You testified that before this incident you were friendly with Ted Weddington.

A. Yes.

Q. Now, isn’t it true that after this incident you weren’t as friendly any more with each other, is that correct?

A. At the very beginning of the accident we were still good friends. We both rode to the hospital.

Q. I understand that and obviously both of you were concerned about this child, is that right?

A. Definitely.

Q. But after that you were no longer friendly, is that correct?

A. Yes, I believe ...

Q. You can answer it yes or no.

THE COURT: On television they make you answer yes or no. Just go ahead and answer it please.

THE WITNESS: Yes. The whole thing got nasty.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.