Supreme Court of Vermont April 6, 1990, 89-130 (State v. Platt)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-04-1990

Gibson, J.

Appellant State of Vermont, by interlocutory appeal, seeks reversal of a pretrial order suppressing evidence obtained from defendant’s automobile, which had been seized without a warrant pursuant to a murder investigation. We reverse and remand the case to the trial court for further proceedings.

I.

In February of 1987, the Vermont state police became involved in the investigation of a homicide when the New Hampshire state police, who had found an unidentified body in a rest area in that state, linked the victim to a residence in Vermont. Based on information supplied by two informants, the police suspected that defendant and another individual had committed the homicide. On March 16, 1987, the two suspects, having learned of police suspicions, left Vermont and headed for New York. The police searched defendant’s room that same day with the consent of his landlord, and on the three subsequent days pursuant to two warrants. The second warrant, issued on March 19, was partly predicated on new information provided by another informant, who, after previous denials, confessed that he himself had acted as a lookout while defendant and another individual committed the crime.

On that same day, an arrest warrant was issued for defendant and the other suspect, and the Vermont police sent out a teletype to other jurisdictions, including Massachusetts, requesting that authorities arrest the suspects and hold their vehicle. No warrant was issued for the search or seizure of the vehicle.

*182

Having been informed that defendant’s car may have been left in Greenfield, Massachusetts, the Vermont police telephoned the Massachusetts state police on March 20 and asked them to look for the car there.

The Massachusetts police located the car legally parked in a large parking lot in an open mall and seized the vehicle without searching it and without knowing whether Vermont had a warrant to seize it.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.