Court of Special Appeals of Maryland June 4, 1990, 1493 September Term, 1989 (Cole v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-06-1990
MOYLAN, Judge.
The appellant, Paul Martin Cole, was convicted by a Carroll County jury of a sexual offense in the second degree. Upon this appeal, he raises the following three contentions:
*284
1. That the evidence was not legally sufficient to sustain the conviction;
2. That the trial judge erroneously admitted as rebuttal evidence prior consistent statements made by the ten-year-old victim; and
3. That the trial judge erroneously denied the appellant’s motion for a new trial after the discovery of allegedly exculpatory evidence.
On Saturday, October 29, 1988, the appellant was living with Barbara Stoffa,
1
the mother of ten-year-old Amy Stoffa. Amy testified that shortly after her mother left for work that day, she went into the bedroom to take the appellant a cup of coffee. The appellant told her to undress, got Vaseline from under the bed, put it on his penis and her anus, and engaged in anal intercourse.
There was corroborative testimony as well. Barbara Stoffa testified that on Tuesday, November 1, three days after the attack, her daughter complained to her of having been sexually assaulted. On the following morning, Barbara Stoffa took her daughter to a pediatrician, Dr. Anthony Vazzano. Dr. Vazzano testified that Amy related the incident to him in a way consistent with her testimony at trial. He further testified to discovering an anal cut consistent with the sexual abuse charged. After Dr. Vazzano reported the incident to the Department of Social Services, Mr. Charles Bosley, a Child Protective Services Worker at the Department of Social Services, conducted an investigation. On Thursday morning, November 3, he and Maryland State Trooper Carol Dorn interviewed Amy in the presence of her mother. Trooper Dorn testified that Amy described the offense that; had occurred on the previous Saturday. Mr. Bosley also ■ testified to the fact of Amy’s complaint.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit