Court of Appeals of Texas July 17, 1990, 9719 (Estate of Menifee v. Barrett)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-07-1990

OPINION

GRANT, Justice.

The Estate of Jessie Beatrice Menifee appeals from a judgment based upon an instructed verdict granted to Robert E. Barrett. The guardian of Menifee’s estate brought this action in a trespass to try title against Barrett challenging ownership of a 47.639 acre tract of land in Camp County which Menifee had deeded to Barrett.

Menifee contends that the trial court erred in granting Barrett an instructed verdict, in striking her pleadings which alleged lack of mental capacity, undue influence and conversion, and in finding that she had not sustained her burden of proof on the issue of failure of consideration.

On September 6, 1982, Menifee signed a warranty deed conveying a 47.639 acre tract of land to Barrett. As consideration for this conveyance, Barrett executed a promissory note for $23,819.50 to be paid in installments of $3,000 per year with no interest until after the maturity of the note and with the provision that the note would be declared paid in full upon the death of Jessie Menifee, who was eighty-one years old when the instrument was executed. On September 11, 1982, Barrett signed a document agreeing to provide Menifee with a place other than a nursing home to live when and if she became unable to continue to live in her residence because of health problems.

We shall first discuss Menifee’s contention that the trial court erred in striking a portion of her pleadings. According to an order

1

made at a hearing on October 3, 1988, and pursuant to an agreement between counsel, Menifee was required to replead her cause of action by October 7, 1988. Menifee did not file her second amended original petition until October 11, 1988. At the beginning of the trial on October 17, 1988, the court ordered all of Menifee’s pleadings stricken which contained allegations of a lack of mental capacity, undue influence, cloud on title and slander of title.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.