Idaho Supreme Court January 3, 1990, 17848 to 17851 (Pintlar Corp. v. Bunker Ltd. Partnership)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-01-1990

BOYLE, Justice.

On November 1, 1982, Gulf Resources and Chemical Corporation (Gulf) and Bunker Hill (now Pintlar) sold the Bunker Hill Mine, associated assets and real property located in Shoshone County to the Bunker Limited Partnership, whose principal place of business is in Shoshone County. Bunker

*154

Limited has one general partner, BH Properties. The limited partners in Bunker Limited are Harry F. Magnuson, a resident of Shoshone County; Hagadone-Idaho, Inc., an Idaho corporation with its principal place of business in Kootenai County; the Simplot Development Corporation, an Idaho corporation with its principal place of business in Ada County; and Jack W. Kendrick, a resident of Shoshone County.

The written purchase agreement consists of a number of contracts and agreements including Limited Guaranties signed by Simplot Development, Hagadone Corporation and Harry F. Magnuson.

On October 30, 1987, Gulf and Pintlar filed suit in Ada County against all defendants, alleging breach of express contract of various terms of the asset purchase agreement and breach of the Agreement of Assumption on the part of Bunker Limited, and tortious interference with the contract on the part of Harry F. Magnuson. Pintlar and Gulf contend that they are entitled to relief against Magnuson, Hagadone and Simplot Development pursuant to the guaranty provisions.

After the complaint was filed, defendants moved for a change of venue. The district court denied the motion, finding that Ada County was a proper venue. Defendants filed a motion to reconsider and alternatively for leave to appeal. The district court denied both motions. On October 20, 1988, this Court granted the defendants’ petitions for permission to appeal.

I.

Venue and Necessary Parties.

Defendants contend that Simplot Development, as a limited partner and guarantor, is not a necessary party to the resolution of the principal dispute between plaintiffs and Bunker Limited partnership.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.