Connecticut Superior Court October 23, 1990, No. 37 75 76. (Colonial Exchange Limited v. Burns, No. 37 75 76 (Oct. 23, 1990))

Also known as

United States · · · 23-10-1990

[EDITOR'S NOTE: This case is unpublished as indicated by the issuing court.] MEMORANDUM OF DECISION This is an appeal by the plaintiff from the defendant's assessment of damages for the taking of the portion of its property and certain rights, as more fully set forth in "Notice of Condemnation" — Exhibit A. The premises are situated in the Town of Farmington on Route 4 and involve the frontage of the plaintiff's large shopping center. Taken on December 6, 1989 were a slope easement, a right to construct a driveway at the main entrance and a right to install a concrete 18" pipe at a designated point as shown on the map. These rights cover 0.024 of an acre. The plaintiff, through its appraiser and a nursery specialist, was permitted to submit evidence as to the costs of replacing various shrubs and plantings, not as an element of damage, but for the purpose of showing market value. Plunske v. Wood, Commissioner, 171 Conn. 280. However, because there was no adequate proof to show to a material degree that the shrubs in question were located within the taking area, it is concluded that the plaintiff has failed in its burden of proof as to this element. In fact, the plaintiff has failed to sustain its burden of proof as to all the other elements except for the value of the land taken. In order to recoup this loss of damage, the plaintiff's appraiser, in rebuttal, adopted the defendant's appraiser's report and testified that in his opinion, 2439 square feet at $8.00 per square foot yielded a total damage of $19,512.00. However, it is found that the appraisal of $3.50 per square foot is a reasonable one. In all, a small amount of land is subjected to a slope easement together with a right to slightly flare out the main driveway. The defendant's appraiser assesses the damage to the easement area at 2439 per square foot times $3.50 per square foot times 20%. The 20% figure is based on the limited extent to which the land was subjected.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.