Ohio Court of Appeals October 19, 1990, Case 13-90-3 (Vaughn v. Vernon Sales Promotions)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-10-1990
KEEFE, J.
This action has had a somewhat troubled journey from its genesis in the Small Claims Division of the Tiffin Municipal Court in October, 1988. The matter eventuated in the common pleas court as a claim by James E. Vaughn against Vernon Sales Promotions and a counterclaim by Vernon Sales contra Vaughn. Two agreements, both involving Vaughn and Vernon Sales, constitute the crux of these appeals.
1
The agreements include almost identical language in one particular provision which stipulates as follows:
"Final acceptance of it [this agreement] is made at Newton, Iowa, and it shall be deemed an Iowa contract, the validity, meaning, and enforcement whereof, and the consequence of a breach of which,
shall be governed by laws of Iowa."
[Underscoring for emphasis.]
2
An eight-hour trial was held on the respective claims of the parties and subsequently the court decided
inter alia
as follows:
"The court, in examining the documents, finds that each contract is controlled by the law of Iowa. No one has cited this court to any Iowa law *** .
"There is nothing in front of the court to indicate what Iowa law would require. As a result, this court finds that both sides have failed to meet their burden of proof since this court has no way of knowing what that burden of proof requires.
"It is therefore, ordered, adjudged and decreed that plaintiff shall receive the sum of zero ($0.00) from the defendant and defendant shall receive the sum of zero ($0.00) from the plaintiff."
*96
Thus, the parties were nonsuited. Both parties appeal from the somewhat singular decision below. They seek reversal, remand and a decision on the merits. Their mutual desire is to have Ohio law applied, obviously preferring to circumvent Iowa law notwithstanding the aforementioned provision of the agreements.
Appellant Vernon Sales advances three assignments of error; cross-appellant Vaughn, one. There is no purpose served by reproducing them here.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit