Oregon Tax Court March 1, 1990, TC 2799 (Philip Morris, Inc. v. Department of Revenue)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-03-1990

CARL N. BYERS, Judge.

Plaintiff is a Virginia corporation which manufactures and sells tobacco products throughout the United States. Defendant determined that plaintiff owed Multnomah County Business Income Taxes (MCBIT) for the years 1976 through 1979. (Opinion and Order No. 85-1127.) Plaintiff contends that it is not liable for such taxes and appeals from defendant’s assessment.

Plaintiff ships its products to its warehouse in Clackamas County.

1

Plaintiff’s customers, wholesale distributors, pick up the products and tobacco tax stamps from the warehouse and take them to their own warehouses. They then affix the tax stamps and prepare the products for sale. These distributors typically carry several brands of cigarettes, candy, gum, etc. The distributors’ sales representatives solicit orders and deal with complaints from retail stores. The activities of the distributors’ sales representatives are not part of plaintiffs activities and are not in question.

During the years in question, plaintiffs activities in Multnomah County were solely those of its sales representative, Mike Weber. Mr. Weber’s testimony described the duties and business activities of a sales representative (sales rep). Plaintiff’s sales reps are salaried employees. They receive no bonuses or commissions as a result of their activities. Plaintiff furnishes each sales rep a vehicle and a modest operating fund. The sales reps do not solicit orders. Although they encourage the retailers to order plaintiffs products, all orders are placed with the distributors, not with plaintiff. The sales rep’s primary function is to promote plaintiffs products and retailer goodwill. They work with the retailers, suggesting ways to increase sales, rearrange displays or demonstrate how to display the product effectively. They set up promotional displays offering the consumers additional benefits for buying plaintiffs products, such as belt buckles or sweat outfits.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.