Supreme Judicial Court of Maine May 3, 1990 (Hayden Brook Logging, Inc. v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-05-1990

HORNBY, Justice.

Hayden Brook Logging, Inc., an employer, brought this declaratory judgment action against the State to establish that federal labor law preempts a state statute regulating the hiring of replacement workers during a strike. The statute, 26 M.R. S.A. § 595 (1988), provides that an employer may not engage in specified hiring activities at any of its sites where a labor dispute, strike or walkout is occurring, that an employer must find a separate location at which to engage in these hiring activities and that an employer must notify the county and municipal law enforcement agencies of this new location at least ten days before it begins hiring activities.1 On the employer’s motion for summary judgment, the Superior Court (Kennebec County, Brody, C.J.) ruled that the National Labor Relations Act, 29 Ü.S.C. § 151-68 (1973), preempts the Maine statute. We conclude that this case does not present a justiciable issue. We therefore vacate the judgment of the Superior Court and, without reaching the merits, remand with instructions to dismiss the action.

Hayden Brook’s employees notified the company that they were going to strike. Hayden Brook wanted to hire replacement workers. According to the evidence submitted on the motion, the company had planned to hire replacement workers by telephone. On advice of counsel, the company concluded that the Maine statute required it to notify the relevant county and town law enforcement agencies ten days before it began hiring. It contacted law enforcement authorities but, before the ten days elapsed, the strikers returned to work. Hayden Brook filed this declaratory judgment action after the work stoppage had ended. Thus, the company no longer wants to hire replacement workers. Although the company claims to have lost revenues during the period when it did not hire replacement workers, Hayden Brook is not seeking damages.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.