Missouri Court of Appeals March 6, 1990, No. 56362 (Lorenz v. City of Florissant)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-03-1990

CARL R. GAERTNER, Judge.

This is the second appeal concerning appellants’ application for certain zoning variances and respondent City’s denial of same. We affirm.

Appellants purchased a home lying within the “H” Historic District in Florissant in January, 1984. The structure had been designated as a landmark building in 1981, but appellants’ title did not indicate this.1 In February, 1984, appellants filed applications for variances with the City’s Planning and Zoning Commission as required by § 30.5(5) of the Zoning Code of the City of Florissant. The Commission, pursuant to § 30.5(6) of the Zoning Code, denied appellants’ requested variances to install vinyl siding, front porch turned posts, front porch concrete steps, front porch turned spindles, scalloped facia boards, and a front door with stained and etched glass, because the additions would not preserve the historic architecture and aesthetics of the house and neighborhood required by the Zoning Code. Appellants appealed to the City Council pursuant to § 30.5(9) of the Zoning Code. After a lengthy hearing conducted over two evening sessions, the Council affirmed the Commission’s denial.

Appellants then filed a petition for administrative review to the Circuit Court under § 536.100 RSMo (1978). The Circuit Court affirmed all denials except the application for vinyl siding. Both parties appealed to this Court. We reversed and remanded the Circuit Court’s decision concerning the vinyl siding because it improperly considered additional evidence not before the City Council, and affirmed the other five denials. Lorenz v. City of Flor-*777issant, 747 S.W.2d 222 (Mo.App.1988) (hereinafter Lorenz I).

Upon remand, the City Council reconsidered appellants’ application for vinyl siding in light of the additional evidence, and again denied appellant’s request. The Circuit Court affirmed the City Council’s decision, and appellants again appeal.

Our standard of review is well settled.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.