Missouri Court of Appeals June 12, 1990, No. 56006 (Minden v. Otis Elevator Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-06-1990

CRANDALL, Judge.

Plaintiff, Thomas A. Minden, was employed by Cassidy Plastering Co., Inc. (Cas-sidy). Cassidy subcontracted with a general contractor, McCarthy Brothers Construction Co. (McBro), to do drywall plastering for the restoration of an office building. Plaintiff was injured when the elevator platform (staging) he was riding fell a distance of about 54 feet before coming to an abrupt stop.

Plaintiff sued subcontractor, Otis Elevator Co. (Otis), for negligently inspecting, repairing, operating, and/or maintaining the staging. Otis then brought a third-party action against Cassidy for contractual indemnity. The claim for bodily injury was tried before a jury, resulting in a $150,000 judgment in favor of plaintiff and against Otis. The third-party claim was severed and tried without a jury, resulting in a judgment for Cassidy. Otis, defendant/third-party plaintiff, appeals from both judgments. We affirm.

The first two points of Otis on appeal claim error in the jury-tried case. We review that evidence in the light most favorable to the verdict. Massey-Ferguson Credit Corp. v. Black, 764 S.W.2d 137, 145 (Mo.App.1989). A jury verdict will not be overturned unless there is a complete absence of probative facts to support the verdict. Id.

McBro subcontracted with Otis to install elevators in the building. Otis installed, maintained and operated a staging in one of the elevator shafts to move construction tools and workers during the construction process.

There were three means of controlling the movement of the staging. First, a worker on the ground floor could operate a hoist that controlled a cable. The cable extended the entire length of the shaft, over the top beam and back down the shaft, where it attached to the staging. Second, a worker riding the staging could operate a skyclimber, which is a motorized device attached to the staging. A short cable hanging from the top beam threads through the skyclimber and then through a hole in the staging.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.