Court of Appeals of Kentucky June 15, 1990, No. 90-CA-60-S (ITT Fluid Products Corp. v. Crane Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-06-1990

McDONALD, Judge.

The question on appeal is whether the vendor/retailer may recoup the payment of a sales tax from the vendee/consumer after the contract has been performed.

ITT Fluid Products Corporation f/d/b/a Grinnell Corporation (ITT) sold to Crane Company (Crane) machinery and equipment by contract dated August 12, 1985. Provision for the payment of sales tax pursuant to KRS 139.2001 was not addressed by the contract. Subsequently, ITT was adjudged by the Kentucky Revenue Cabinet to be liable for payment of $31,300 in sales tax. ITT paid the tax.

Subsequent to the cabinet’s ruling and three years after the contract, ITT filed suit against Crane to collect the sales tax it paid pursuant to KRS 139.210, which provides: “The taxes herein imposed may be collected by the retailer from the consumer.” The circuit court dismissed ITT’s complaint summarily, which brings the issue before us.

ITT argues that the vendee/consumer bears the economic burden of the sales tax, citing Marcum v. City of Louisville Municipal Housing Com’n, Ky., 374 S.W.2d 865, 866 (1963), and that while some states limit the vendor’s right to collect the tax to the time of the transaction, Kentucky’s statutes do not do so.

The contract, as negotiated and executed, was silent as to payment of the sales tax by either party, and because the vendee/consumer bears the economic burden of the tax by statute, Crane should be liable. Because there are no Kentucky case authorities on point, we are guided solely by the statutory authority of KRS 139.210 which explicitly gives the vendor/retailer the right to collect the tax.

While we do not reject the arguments of ITT outright, its reasoning stops short of a more logical conclusion. Crane’s argument *845points out that KRS 139.200 imposes the sales tax upon the vendor/retailer for the privilege of doing business in the Commonwealth, and under KRS 139.210 the tax may be collected from the vendee/consumer.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.