Court of Appeals of Utah August 15, 1990, No. 890177-CA (Little v. Greene & Weed Investments)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-08-1990

OPINION

DAVIDSON, Judge:

Appellant appeals the trial court’s decision awarding water rights to the appel-lees.1 We affirm.

On January 16, 1968, Lester F. Little and Madge Little, husband and wife, conveyed to their five children by warranty deed 80.1 acres of land located in the Johnson Canyon area in Kanab, Utah. The deed conveyed to each an undivided one-fifth interest “[t]ogether with all improvements and appurtenances appertaining thereto.” At the time of the conveyance the water right later associated with the land had not yet been certificated by the state engineer. This water right was carved out of a larger water right application originally filed by Lester on April 12, 1955 and approved by the state engineer on October 15,1958. On November 30, 1967, Lester filed the application to segregate the water right in question. The new application requested permission to appropriate .92 cubic feet per second (cfs) out of the 10 cfs in the original application for use on 83.3 acres. The state engineer opened a new file upon receiving the segregated application.

Lester constructed diversion facilities and irrigated the 83.3 acres beginning in the early part of 1967. On December 19, 1967, Lester filed proof of appropriation with the state engineer demonstrating that the diversion facilities were complete and that the water had been placed to beneficial use. Approximately one month after filing the proof of appropriation, but prior to certification, Lester conveyed 80.1 of the 83.3 acres to his five children.

The five children made several conveyances further dividing the land. Appellant contends that the initial warranty deed from Lester and Madge to the five children transferred the water right as an appurtenance to the land. Therefore, the subsequent warranty deeds issued by the children also passed the water rights, and the quitclaim deeds and other documents relied upon by appellees are irrelevant to the court’s determination of title to the water.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.