Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit March 1, 1990, 800, Docket 89-7861 (Carole Heller Weitzman, as Assignee of Saul Weitzman v. Sidney Stein, Albert Feiffer and Norman Rubinson v. Beverly Stein)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-03-1990
KEARSE, Circuit Judge:
In this action, which dates back to 1970 and was perhaps presciently described by a district court judge several years ago as “interminable,” respondent Beverly Stein appeals from an order of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York, David N. Edelstein,
Judge,
freezing her assets except for a $2,000 per month living allowance. On appeal, she contends principally (1) that the district court did not have personal jurisdiction over her, (2) that the plaintiff had not made a showing sufficient to warrant injunctive relief, and (3) that the court failed to make findings and follow proper procedures prior to entering the injunction. For the reasons below, we conclude that the injunction was improperly entered, and we vacate and remand for further proceedings.
I. BACKGROUND
In 1978, a judgment was entered in this action after a trial before Lloyd F. MacMahon,
Judge,
in favor of Saul Weitz-man against defendants Sidney Stein (“Sidney”) and others, in the amount of $89,-703.03, plus interest and costs. Saul Weitz-man assigned the judgment to Carole Heller Weitzman (“Weitzman”). Respondent Beverly Stein (“Beverly”), Sidney’s wife, was not a party to the action. The present appeal emanates from Weitzman’s continuing efforts to enforce the judgment.
Supplemental proceedings following the 1978 judgment resulted in the district court’s declaring that Sidney was the alter ego of two corporations, F.I.F. Consultants, Inc., and Investment Bancshares, Inc., and ordering Sidney to account for and turn over to the court all assets of the two corporations, as well as all other assets in his possession. Memorandum of Judge MacMahon dated May 20, 1986. Sidney failed to comply with this order and alleged that he had given his assets to Beverly. In 1987, after the case had been reassigned to Judge Edelstein, an amended judgment was entered in the sum of $442,729.33, including interest, costs, and attorneys’ fees.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit