Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit May 24, 1990, 761, 864, Dockets 89-7982, -7984 (Prime Management Company, Incorporated, Cross-Appellee v. John F. Steinegger and Nancy J. Steinegger, D/B/A Franz Melzer Associates, Cross-Appellants)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-05-1990

KEARSE, Circuit Judge:

Plaintiff Prime Management Company, Incorporated (“Prime”), appeals from so much of a judgment entered in the United States District Court for the District of Connecticut after a bench trial before Ellen Bree Burns,

Chief Judge,

as awarded defendants John F. Steinegger and Nancy J. Steinegger, d/b/a Franz Melzer Associates (defendants and their associated business entities collectively referred to hereafter as “Steinegger”), $161,542.05 as damages on their counterclaim for Prime’s underpayment of rents due under a May 1972 lease agreement (the “rent counterclaim”), plus attorney’s fees. On appeal, Prime contends that the rent counterclaim should have been dismissed on grounds of res judicata. Steinegger cross-appeals from so much of the judgment as denied it prejudgment interest on the rent counterclaim, denied it attorney’s fees expended for the successful defense of Prime’s complaint, and dismissed its suit to evict Prime from the rented premises.

I. BACKGROUND

In May 1972, Prime Motor Inns, Inc., which was Prime’s parent company, and Steinegger entered into a contract pursuant to which Steinegger was to convert a partially constructed office building in Stamford, Connecticut, into a motel. Concurrently, Prime agreed to lease from Steinegger the real property on which the building was situated.

A.

The Terms of the Lease

The 1972 lease agreement (“lease”) provided for an initial term of 25 years, plus two ten-year extensions. The lease required Prime to pay rent annually, consisting of a base rent

equal to the amount of money needed each year to amortize the total amount of the permanent mortgage placed on the demised premises over a period of twenty (20) years ...

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.