Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit June 8, 1990, 87-2206 (Sam H. Bennion v. Utex Oil Company, a Utah Corporation, and Shell Western E & P, Inc., a Delaware Corporation Shell Oil Co., a Delaware Corporation)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-06-1990
LOGAN, Circuit Judge.
Plaintiff Sam H. Bennion, a nonconsent-ing mineral owner under the Utah Oil and Gas Conservation Act, Utah Code Ann. §§ 40-6-1 to 40-6-18, brought this diversity suit seeking to compel defendants Shell Western E & P, Inc. and Shell Oil Company (collectively “Shell”) to pay him his share of the production proceeds from oil and gas wells in which he had an interest. Plaintiff also sought punitive damages for Shell’s alleged willful and malicious failure to pay his proportionate share of production. The district court held that plaintiff was not entitled to punitive damages as a matter of law and excluded all evidence on the issue. Plaintiff appeals this ruling.
1
We affirm.
Plaintiff has mineral interests in several oil and gas wells in Duchesne County, Utah, which are now under a forced pooling order. Shell was the operator of one of these wells and processed the oil and gas from the other wells under an agreement with the operator to pay plaintiff his share of the proceeds. Plaintiff never entered a lease, operating agreement, division order, gas processing contract, or any other agreement with respect to the operation of any of the wells. His right to production from the wells, therefore, is governed by the “nonconsenting owner” provisions of Utah Code Ann. § 40-6-6(6) to -6(8).
One of the wells at issue was the subject of an order of the Utah Board of Oil, Gas and Mining (Board) which gave plaintiff a full accounting of his share of production as of July 26, 1979, and gave him a right to receive his share in kind thereafter. The Utah Supreme Court affirmed that order in
Bennion v. Utah State Bd. of Oil, Gas & Mining,
675 P.2d 1135 (Utah 1983). Thereafter, plaintiff received his in kind share until October 15, 1981, but he stopped paying his proportionate share of operating expenses for the well on February 29,1980, and he received no other production or proceeds from that well.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit