Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit August 14, 1990, 89-1420 (Whittaker Corporation, by Its Technibilt Division v. Unr Industries, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-08-1990

ARCHER, Circuit Judge.

UNR Industries, Inc. (UNR) appeals from the summary judgment granted by the United States District Court for the Western District of North Carolina, No. C-C-88-0110-M (Mar. 22, 1989), holding United States Patent No. Re. 32,453 (the ’453 patent) “invalid ... under the ‘Recapture Rule’ ”

(citing Ball Corp. v. United States,

729 F.2d 1429, 221 USPQ 289 (Fed.Cir.1984)). We reverse and remand.

I

The ’453 patent is a reissue of United States Patent No. 4,423,882 (the ’882 patent). The patented invention is directed to a “Shopping Cart With Baby Seat.”

In its reissue application, which was filed less than two years following the issuance of the ’882 patent, UNR sought to broaden the scope of the ’882 claims by removing one of the limitations that had been added during prosecution of the ’882 patent.

See

35 U.S.C. § 251 (1988).

1

Neither the grounds for reissue (“through error without any deceptive intention”) nor the broadened scope of the claims of the reissued patent are challenged by Whittaker in this appeal.

Rather, the only question before us is whether the district court’s determination on summary judgment that “the claims of the '453 reissue patent do not differ materially from the claims that were surrendered to obtain the allowance of the original [’882] patent” reflects a correct construction of the claims. In reaching this conelu

*711

sion, the district court held that another limitation, added during prosecution of the ’882 patent and retained in the same form in independent claims 1 and 22 of the reissued ’453 patent,

2

did not change the “scope of the patent claims” of the application for the ’882 patent.

More specifically, claim 1

3

of the ’453 patent reads in pertinent part as follows:

4

A shopping cart which comprises: ...

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.