Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit September 17, 1990, 89-3642 (Ralph C. SHAGER, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. UPJOHN COMPANY and Asgrow Seed Company, Defendants-Appellees)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-09-1990
POSNER, Circuit Judge.
Ralph Shager appeals from the dismissal of his suit under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (29 U.S.C. §§ 621
et seq.),
following a motion for summary judgment made by his former employer, the Asgrow Seed Company, and its successor and code-fendant, Upjohn Company. The grant of summary judgment was proper only if, on the facts before the district judge, taken as favorably to Shager as the evidence permitted, no reasonable jury could conclude that Asgrow had fired him because of his age.
Shager was employed by a manufacturer of seeds that was bought by Asgrow in 1983, when he was fifty years old. His job was sales representative for the State of Wisconsin, and required him to supervise the company’s sales force in the state — a force of farmers working parttime as seed salesmen. Asgrow kept Shager, at first with the same responsibilities. He reported to John Lehnst, Asgrow’s youngest district manager (thirty-five years old in 1983), who was in charge of the company’s sales representatives in several midwestern states. There were nine such representatives, six older than Lehnst, of whom five were in their fifties.
Shortly after the acquisition, Asgrow hired a second sales representative for Wisconsin, Eugene Stouffer. Stouffer was forty-eight years old, and Lehnst, troubled by the disparity in ages between himself and most of his subordinates, asked Stouf-fer several times during the pre-hire interview whether he would mind being supervised by a younger man; he said he would not. After Stouffer came on the scene, Lehnst divided the Wisconsin territory into a northern and a southern part — rejecting Shager’s suggestion that it be divided along east/west lines instead. The northern part was more challenging; it was larger and its farmland was of poorer quality, depressing the demand for seeds. Lehnst assigned the northern part to Shager and the southern to Stouffer.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit