Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit December 11, 1990, 89-3429 (Thomas C. Cadwallader and Judy C. Douglas v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-12-1990

POSNER, Circuit Judge.

The question presented by this appeal from a decision by the Tax Court is whether Thomas Cadwallader, a professor of psychology at Indiana State University, is entitled to a deduction from income tax for the expense of maintaining an office in his home. Cadwallader has the exclusive use of two offices in the psychology department, one 11 feet by 13 feet and the other 12 by 12, plus a 4 by 7 storage room. But he does most of his research and writing in his home office. The statute, so far as relevant here, allows an employee to take a home office deduction only if the office is exclusively used on a regular basis for the convenience of his employer as the employee’s principal place of business. 26 U.S.C. § 280A(c)(l)(A). The Tax Court denied the deduction on the ground that the “focal point” of Cadwallader’s work for the university was the campus, where he teaches thirteen hours a week, meets with students, attends faculty meetings, and keeps substantial research materials. 57 T.C.M. 1030 (1989).

We owe no deference to the Tax Court’s legal theories, our relation to the. Tax Court being the same as our relation to the district courts.

Prussner v. United States,

896 F.2d 218, 224 (7th Cir.1990) (en banc). And, like the Second Circuit in

Weissman v. Commissioner,

751 F.2d 512 (2d Cir.1984), we have rejected the “focal point” test.

Meiers v. Commissioner,

782 F.2d 75, 79 (7th Cir.1986) (per curiam). The facts of

Weissman

show why. Weissman, a professor like Cadwallader, had a campus office, but he shared it with other professors and as a result did all his research and writing at home — in fact he spent eighty percent of his working time at home. The Tax Court thought, nevertheless, that the campus was the focus of his activities. Maybe so — -“focus” is a vague word in this setting — but, reversing the Tax Court, the Second Circuit held that the home office was Weissman’s principal place of business.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.