New York Court of Appeals October 23, 1990 (People v. Gordon)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-10-1990
lead-opinion
OPINION OF THE COURT
Bellacosa, J.
This appeal from an Appellate Division order, affirming a conviction of criminal sale and possession of drugs, turns on the admissibility of a station house showup identification by an undercover police officer. The Court is unanimous that the undercover officer’s December 7, 1984 showup identification of defendant as a participant in a drug sale on November 27, 1984 is irredeemably suggestive and must be suppressed. It is significantly different from the confirmatory type of showup identification by a trained undercover police officer which was circumscribed but allowed in People v Wharton (74 NY2d 921). We therefore reverse, vacate the judgment of conviction, and remit for further proceedings on the indictments. In that connection, if the prosecution intends to provide in-court identification of defendant by the officer at a new trial, the identification must be scrutinized at a Wade hearing to be sure it is free of taint and dependent on an independent source (United States v Wade, 388 US 218; see also, People v Adams, 53 NY2d 241, 251). Finally, the evidence of defendant’s guilt of narcotics possessory crimes on December 7, 1984 is sufficient under our standard review test, giving the People, as we must, every favorable interpretation since they *598persuaded a jury as a matter of fact, beyond a reasonable doubt, that defendant exercised a knowing dominion and control over the drugs.
On November 27, 1984, an undercover police officer, in the course of a drug buy operation, encountered defendant in a Bronx alleyway. Defendant asked if she wanted "coke” and directed her to knock on the door of a nearby house if she did. The undercover officer knocked, was admitted to an apartment, and told the occupants that she wanted to buy some cocaine. Before the buy was completed, defendant also knocked on the door, was admitted, and warned the occupants that the police were outside.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit