Court of Appeals of Georgia May 24, 1990, A90A0134 (Davis v. Knight)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-05-1990

Cooper, Judge.

Appellant filed suit against appellees alleging assault and battery and appellees counterclaimed, also alleging assault and battery and praying for the recovery of expenses, costs and attorney fees. Appellees amended their counterclaim to add a claim for damages, expenses and attorney fees pursuant to Yost v. Torok, 256 Ga. 92 (344 SE2d 414) (1986) and OCGA § 9-15-14. After the close of the evidence, in a jury trial, appellees withdrew their “Yost” and § 9-15-14 claim. The jury returned verdicts for the appellant against appellee Knight in the amount of $778.50; for the appellant against appellee Comer in the amount of -0-; for the appellant against appellees, jointly and severally in the amount of -0-; for appellee Knight against appellant in the amount of -0-; and for appellee Comer against appellant in the amount of $2,300, and this appeal is taken from the judgment entered thereon.

1. In his first and fourth enumerations, appellant contends the trial court erred in allowing appellees to amend their counterclaim and in denying appellant’s motion to dismiss the amendment to the counterclaim. The record reflects that the appellees withdrew the amendment to the counterclaim at the close of the evidence, however appellant presented no evidence that he was harmed by the judge’s actions. Therefore, if any error did occur (which we do not decide), it was harmless and does not require reversal. Kolman, Inc. v. Burns, 191 Ga. App. 758 (382 SE2d 702) (1989).

2. Appellant next contends that the court erred in admitting testimony of a witness concerning conversations the witness had with appellees after the incident occurred. From the record, it appears that appellant’s objection was based upon the irrelevancy of the testimony because it related to a time period other than the time of the incident. No other grounds for the objection appear in the record. Objections based on the irrelevancy of evidence are insufficient to show reversible error. Brinson v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.