New York Supreme Court January 17, 1990 (Carroll v. Nunez)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-01-1990

*423OPINION OF THE COURT

Joseph Harris, J.

Defendant Nunez moves to preclude plaintiff from offering expert proof at trial, based upon the plaintiff’s alleged failure to comply with defendant’s demand for expert’s identity. Plaintiff cross-moves against both defendants for the identical relief.

The instant case presents important issues regarding the proper content of expert demands under recently amended CPLR 3101 (d), which amendment was part of the comprehensive medical malpractice bill of 1985 (L 1985, ch 294), the adequacy of responses thereto, and the practice of "eve of trial” retention of experts.

The instant malpractice action was commenced by service of a summons on January 13, 1986. Issue was joined on March 12, 1986, on which date defendant, Nunez, served plaintiff with a demand for expert’s identity. Those portions of defendant’s demand which are objected to by the plaintiff are as follows:

"5. Dates of all reports rendered by each expert.

"6. The qualifications of each expert witness, including:

"(a) Colleges and universities attended and degrees earned, if any, including dates of attendance;

"(b) All internships, residencies and fellowships including location and dates;

"(c) All dates in which the expert has been licensed including present licensure;

"(d) Any professional certifications, including dates thereof; "(e) All current professional society memberships;

"(f) All past professional society memberships and reasons for termination;

"(g) All past hospital staff appointments and reasons for termination;

"(h) All current hospital staff appointments;

"(i) Whether each expert has published, in the speciality at issue.”

On March 6, 1989, the parties appeared at a preliminary conference before the Honorable Aaron E. Klein, Judicial Hearing Officer, and plaintiff agreed to provide both defendants with a response to their respective expert demands.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.