Civil Court of the City of New York December 14, 1990 (1515 Macombs Rd. Corp. v. Austin)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-12-1990

OPINION OF THE COURT

Carl O. Callender, J.

The essential question in this case relates to the fundamental fairness extant in a holdover proceeding against a deceased tenant and the occupants of the apartment when the estate of the decedent has not been served or named as a party. In the present case the deceased tenant died in July 1990, and the petitioner sought the premises the following month. No mention was made in any of the papers about the fact that the tenant (Irene Austin) was deceased. Nor did the petitioner make any inquiry about the relationship between the present occupants and the deceased tenant. The petitioner also did not attempt to serve or name a representative of the deceased *474tenant (executor, executrix, administrator, administatrix). Further, the petitioner failed to investigate to determine whether a representative of the decedent tenant’s estate had engaged in efforts to secure and maintain the decedent’s interest in the subject premises. Consequently, no representative of the deceased tenant was named or served in the instant proceeding.

The petitioner’s counsel argues that there is no need for further inquiry or action on the petitioner’s part, because those are matters for the present occupants to assert. Since they have failed to appear at the trial and assert those claims, why is the court concerned, counsel queries?

At the inquest, where the deceased tenant is named as a party, and no representative of the deceased is named or served, who else would be required to be concerned and to speak up, but the court. In addition to the deceased tenant, the occupants John and Jane Doe were served by conspicuous service.

This court believes that justice and due process require more than has been meted out in the instant case.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.