Massachusetts Appeals Court January 3, 1990, No. 88-P-511 (Jackson v. Stuhlfire)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-01-1990

As styled by the named plaintiffs, the complaint was brought by them “On Behalf of Themselves and All Other Fellowship Members,” that is, the membership of the Norfolk Fellowship Foundation, Inc. (NFF). The allegations of the complaint speak to violations of the laws of the Commonwealth (without reference to any specific statute) and of the rights of the membership majority. Damages were sought on behalf of the membership, payable to the NFF. Concluding that the action was a derivative one, the judge allowed the defendants’ motion for summary judgment on the stated bases that the plaintiffs had failed to show compliance with Mass.R.Civ.P. 23.1, 365 Mass. 768-769 (1974), or that the acts complained of were anything more than reasonable business decisions made in good faith. On appeal, the plaintiffs argue that the complaint was not intended as being a derivative action but was, instead, brought to vindicate their civil rights. We affirm.

As described by the judge in her memorandum of decision, the NFF was founded in 1957 to promote interaction between inmates at the Massachusetts Correctional Institution, Norfolk, and volunteer members of the community. Its purpose was to assist inmates in adjusting to prison life and to prepare them for return to their communities. Since 1957, the NFF has grown and become more structured. It is now a nonprofit corporation with a board of directors, articles of organization, corporate by-laws and a membership which, through amendments to the by-laws, includes inmates from eight correctional institutions in addition to M.C.I., Norfolk.

1. The nature of the action. “We treat pleadings according to their nature and substance. See Commonwealth v. Wakelin, 230 Mass. 567, 571 *925[1918]; Essex Trust Co. v. Averill, 321 Mass. 68, 70 [1947]; Employers’ Liab. Assur. Corp., Ltd. v. Traynor, 354 Mass. 763 [1968].” Fabrizio v. U.S. Susuki Motor Corp., 362 Mass. 873 (1972).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.