Massachusetts Appeals Court August 27, 1990, No. 89-P-349 (Costa v. Liberty Mutual Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-08-1990

Kass, J.

Upon a motion for summary judgment by Liberty Mutual Insurance Company (Liberty), a Superior Court judge decided that Liberty, in its position as a workers’ compensation insurer, owed no duty to the plaintiff Michael Costa, an injured employee, to advise him that he had a potential action against the manufacturer of the machine involved in his industrial accident. Judgment was entered for the defendant and the plaintiff has appealed. We affirm.

The dispositive facts, as must be the case when summary judgment is granted, are undisputed. Costa was hurt while *177working on a “mangle” machine.1 Liberty was the workers’ compensation insurer for Costa’s employer, Arkwright Finishing Company. The “mangle” machine was manufactured by Morrison. Textile Machinery Company (Morrison). Liberty made medical payments and disability payments to Costa, provided rehabilitation services, and paid a lump sum settlement of $50,000. Neither Costa, who did not consult a lawyer, nor Liberty brought an action under G. L. c. 152, § 15, against the manufacturer of the “mangle” machine, Morrison, on the ground that its defective design caused Costa’s injury.2 Liberty’s tepid enthusiasm for pursuing Morrison was understandable; it was also Morrison’s insurer.

Costa’s complaint may be read as alleging that Liberty was negligent, at best, or deceitfully in breach of its fiduciary duty to Costa, at worst, in failing to advise him before the statute of limitations ran out (the accident occurred on April 16, 1979) that he might wish to explore the third-party liability of Morrison. There is also a claim under G. L. c. 93A. The action must assume the existence of a duty by a workers’ compensation insurer to advise an employee of potential third-party liability claims. See Dinsky v. Framingham, 386 Mass. 801, 804-805 (1982); Flattery v. Gregory, 397 Mass. 143, 145 (1986).

Under G. L. c.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.