Massachusetts Appeals Court July 30, 1990, Nos. 87-917 & 89-P-918 (Commonwealth v. Capparelli)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-07-1990
The defendant appeals from his convictions on multiple indictments alleging violation of the criminal usury statute, G. L. c. 271, § 49(a), and from the denial of his motion for a new trial. Both appeals focus on alleged *927failures to disclose exculpatory information1 and to preserve a recorded statement of the defendant.
In denying the motion for a new trial, the judge found: (1) that a recording of a telephone conversation between the defendant and a prosecution witness “was for all practical purposes provided to the defendant well prior to trial”; (2) that a tape recording of a conversation between the defendant and Joseph Bonales was “inadvertently misplaced” and that, in any event, any prejudice, to the defendant as a result of the failure to disclose the tape was “impossible to find”; and (3) that certain affidavits executed by the police in support of applications for pen register warrants pursuant to G. L. c. 272, § 99, were devoid of exculpatory material and that the failure to disclose them “resulted in no prejudice to the defendant.” The judge concluded: “An evaluation of this case disclosed that the convictions were supported by overwhelming evidence. No manifest injustice was done. The defendant was not deprived of any defense nor of any material tending to exculpate him.” Giving these carefully crafted findings the deference to which they are entitled, Commonwealth v. Lipomi, 385 Mass. 370, 376 (1982), we find no basis for disturbing the denial of the motion for a new trial. Commonwealth v. Tobin, 392 Mass. 604, 619 (1984).
In the appeal from his convictions, the defendant maintains that various prosecutorial violations of Mass.R.Crim.P. 14, 378 Mass. 874 (1979), denied him due process and a fair trial. In addition to repeating the allegations made in support of his new trial motion, he also argues that the prosecution failed to disclose oral statements of Bonales and to reveal the existence of an understanding with him.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit