New Mexico Court of Appeals March 20, 1990, No. 11977 (Schuch v. Arthritis Foundation)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-03-1990
OPINION
BIVINS, Chief Judge.
Plaintiff appeals thé trial court’s grant of summary judgment to defendant. Our second calendar notice proposed reversal, and defendant has responded with a memorandum in opposition. We are not persuaded by the memorandum and reverse.
In reviewing a grant of summary judgment, we are required to view the evidence in the light most favorable to the party opposing the judgment. In addition, we must draw all reasonable inferences in favor of that party. Knapp v. Fraternal Order of Eagles, 106 N.M. 11, 738 P.2d 129 (Ct.App.1987). Viewed in that light, the facts most favorable to plaintiff, as asserted in her affidavit and deposition, are as follows: (1) defendant’s parking lot was designed in such a way that a parking barrier was located almost directly underfoot anyone exiting the driver’s side of a vehicle parked in the adjacent space; (2) the parking spaces in defendant’s parking lot were too narrow; (3) plaintiff tripped over the barrier while backing away from her car as she was closing her car door. These assertions raise a genuine issue of fact as to whether the placement of the barriers was unreasonably dangerous for persons parking in the lot and exiting their vehicles.
The question of whether a defendant has breached the duty of reasonable care is ordinarily a question of fact to be resolved at trial. See id. Plaintiff’s factual assertions in this case raise a question as to whether defendant violated its duty of care by placing the parking barrier too close to the adjacent parking space and in such a position as to be directly underfoot a person alighting from a car parked in the adjacent space. Although the parking barrier is an open and obvious danger, there is a question as to whether persons exiting their vehicles and preoccupied with that endeavor should reasonably be expected to be aware of and avoid a barrier that is directly underfoot. Cf.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit