Court of Appeals of Arizona April 26, 1990, No. 2 CA-CV 89-0251 (Lindley v. Northwest Hospital & Medical Center, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-04-1990

lead-opinion

OPINION

LACAGNINA, Judge.

The survivors of a decedent, in a wrongful death action based on a physician’s mal*134practice, appeal from an adverse jury verdict and denial of their motion for new trial, raising a number of issues concerning the rulings of the trial court. We reverse the judgment of the trial court and remand for new trial on only one of the issues raised and decline to render an opinion on the other issues, which depend on the manner in which evidence is presented upon retrial.

The survivors argue that the trial court committed error by refusing to strike one of the prospective jurors for cause. See Ariz.R.Civ.P. 47(c)(4) and (5), 16 A.R.S. The right of a party to peremptory challenges is a substantial right, and forcing a party to use his peremptory challenges to strike jurors who should have been stricken for cause deprives that party of a' substantial right and is grounds for reversal. Wasko v. Frankel, 116 Ariz. 288, 569 P.2d 230 (1977). Whether a challenge is allowed or not is within the sound judicial discretion of the trial court. Our examination of the record discloses an abuse of the trial court's discretion in its refusal to strike one of the jurors for cause.

The juror in question was a recent patient of a physician to be called as an expert on behalf of the defendant doctor. The expert’s testimony was one of many opinions to be offered by experts called by both parties, and the basic issue of malpractice and causation was largely dependent upon the opinions of experts. Upon examination by the court, the juror stated the following:

PROSPECTIVE JUROR SHARP: Dr. Dunn just did some surgery on me about a month ago.

THE COURT: Okay. Ms. Sharp, Dr. Dunn will be — is expected to be called as a witness on behalf of the defendants. In other words, the plaintiffs may call witnesses and then the defendants may call witnesses, and Dr. Dunn has been listed as a witness the defendants will call.

Would you, because of having treatment with Dr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.