United States Court of International Trade July 23, 1990, Court No. 89-11-00636 (National Hand Tool Corp. v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-07-1990

Re, Chief Judge:

The question presented in this case pertains to the scope of a protective order requested by plaintiff, National Hand Tool Corporation, pursuant to Rule 26(c) of the Rules of this Court. Plaintiff requests the protective order in an effort to restrict the defendant’s use of information obtained through the discovery process. The defendant objects to the terms of plaintiffs proposed protective order, and has submitted its own proposed order.

The first dispute between the parties pertains to paragraph 6 of the defendant’s proposed protective order, which allows the defendant to disclose plaintiff’s confidential information to “third party consultants and experts” in order to aid in the preparation of its defense. Plaintiff contends that such a disclosure “would cause substantial harm to [plaintiff] if it, or any of it, should fall into the hands of would-be competitors, customers or suppliers or if business decisions by any such firms were aided by persons having knowledge of that data.” Furthermore, plaintiff contends that the defendant has no need to reveal that information to outside experts because the defendant has the necessary personnel within the Customs Service who have experience with these products, and are intimately familiar with the manufacturing process at issue in this case. The parties, however, do not dispute that the information may be disclosed to government employees who assist counsel in conducting the case.

The second dispute between the parties stems from the methods utilized in the designation of confidential information. The third dispute pertains to paragraph 5 (E) of the defendant’s proposed protective order, which permits the defendant to disclose plaintiffs confidential information to persons who had prior access to the information. The fourth and final dispute arises from the method of dealing with the confidential information after the action is concluded.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.