Ohio Court of Appeals November 19, 1990, Case No. CA-8096 (Schnabel v. Whipkey)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-11-1990

HOFFMAN, J.

Plaintiff-appellee in this appeal from a personal injury action is Thomas E. Schnabel; defendant-appellant is Jack Whipkey. Now follows a statement of the facts.

On the evening of July 31, 1987, defendant Whipkey and his house guest, Philip Dobran-sky, were on their way to Bolivar to purchase wasp spray. Along the way, Whipkey decided to show Dobransky a field where he had helped bail hay the prior evening and where he had previously hunted groundhogs.

Whipkey had blanket permission to hunt in this field owned by Frank Habrun and had hunted groundhogs there for the past twenty years without incident. While bailing hay the previous day, he had observed several groundhog holes, and he knew that there were many groundhogs in the field.

While driving down the lane to show the field to Dobransky, Whipkey peered across the field and observed a grayish-brown object in close vicinity to a known groundhog hole. He stopped his pickup truck, took careful aim, and fired his rifle. If developed that what Whipkey believed to be a groundhog was in fact Thomas Schnabel, wearing camouflage clothing, lying prone in the field amongst the groundhog holes. (T. Vol. 4 pp. 10-15).

Schnabel was an experienced hunter having hunted various types of game, including groundhogs, for the past 30 years. (T. Vol. 2 p. 201). He had shot over 100 groundhogs on this particular farm and had hunted groundhog in this particular field 20-30 times in the past two years. (T. Vol. 2 pp. 212, 256). It was his practice to use binoculars and a gun tripod to identify his target and shoot at a range of 50 - 400 yards. (T. Vol. 2 pp. 205, 211). On the evening of the accident, Schnabel was lying prone near the middle of the field within 10-20 feet of several groundhog holes. (T. Vol. 2 pp. 222, 263). His pickup truck was parked behind the second barn and was not visible to anyone driving up the lane from the road as Whipkey was (T. Vol. 2, p. 267).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.