Ohio Supreme Court May 9, 1990, No. 89-497 (Doyle v. Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-05-1990

Alice Robie Re snick, J.

The issue before this court is whether Ohio Adm. Code 4501:1-1-16(B)(1) violates the due course of law provision of Section 16, Article I of the Ohio Constitution. Our determination of this issue also requires an examination of R.C. 4507.08(A). We are cognizant that “[a]n enactment of the General Assembly is presumed to be constitutional, and before a court may declare it unconstitutional it must appear beyond a reasonable doubt that the legislation and constitutional provisions are clearly incompatible.” State, ex rel. Dickman, v. Defenbacher (1955), 164 Ohio St. 142, 57 O.O. 134, 128 N.E. 2d 59, paragraph one of the syllabus. See, also, Rocky River v. State Emp. Relations Bd. (1989), 43 Ohio St. 3d 1, 10, 539 N.E. 2d 103, 111 (long-established principle requiring courts to presume the constitutionality of legislative enactments); State v. Young (1988), 37 Ohio St. 3d 249, 251, 525 N.E. 2d 1363, 1367 (all legislative enactments enjoy a strong presumption of constitutionality); State v. Stambaugh (1987), 34 Ohio St. 3d 34, 35, 517 N.E. 2d 526, 527 (doubts regarding the validity of a statute are to be resolved in favor of the statute); State, ex rel. Swetland, v. Kinney (1982), 69 Ohio St. 2d 567, 23 O.O. 3d 479, 433 N.E. 2d 217.

It should be noted that neither the trial court nor the court of appeals held that R.C. 4507.08 is unconstitutional. Furthermore, appellee does not contend that this statutory provision is constitutionally infirm. R.C. 4507.08 provides in pertinent part:

“No temporary instruction permit or driver’s license shall be issued to, or retained by:

“(A) Any person who is an alcoholic, or is addicted to the use of controlled substances to the extent that the use constitutes an impairment to the person’s ability to operate a motor vehicle with the required degree of safety[.]” (Emphasis added.)

The General Assembly did not define the term “alcoholic” in R.C. 4507.08. However, Ohio Adm.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.