Court of Appeals of Oregon December 19, 1990, LUBA 89-137, 89-138, 89-139, 89-140; CA A66567 (McKay Creek Valley Ass'n v. Washington County)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-12-1990
BUTTLER, P. J.
Petitioner appealed to LUBA from a group of Washington County ordinances that amended provisions of the Community Development Code (CDC) relating, inter alia, to standards for allowing farm and forest dwellings. LUBA affirmed county’s actions in part and remanded them in part. Petitioner seeks review of LUBA’s decision, contending that LUBA erred in rejecting two of its assignments of error. We affirm.
Petitioner contends in its first assignment that the county’s Agricultural and Forestry-20 (AF-20) zone is designated in its comprehensive plan as a mixed agricultural and forestry zone; that both Goal 3 and Goal 4, therefore, apply to it; that county’s amendments allow dwellings and other uses in the zone if they meet state and local criteria for permitted uses in exclusive farm use (EFU) zones, but do not require that the uses also meet applicable tests for development on forest land; that LUBA erred by concluding that AF-20 is designated in the plan as an EFU zone only, rather than a mixed farm-forestry zone; and that LUBA, accordingly, erred by concluding that Goal 4 is inapplicable to the amendments.
County’s comprehensive plan has several components, including the CDC and the Rural/Natural Resources Plan. Petitioner relies on various provisions in the latter to support its contention that AF-20 is a mixed zone rather than an exclusive farm use zone. Read alone, the Rural/Natural Resources Plan is ambiguous about the question. However, the CDC contains provisions, on which LUBA relied, which pre-date the challenged amendments and are acknowledged as complying with the goals and which make it clear that AF-20 is solely an EFU designation. Petitioner argues that the CDC is a zoning ordinance and, as such, its provisions are subordinate to the designation in the Rural/Natural Resources Plan, a part of the comprehensive plan.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit