Indiana Supreme Court December 13, 1990, No. 52S04-9012-JV-781 (In re C.P.)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-12-1990

SHEPARD, Chief Justice.

The question is whether patient communications to a counselor who is supervised by a psychiatrist fall within the doctor-patient privilege. We hold that a counselor who aids the psychiatrist is covered by the privilege. By contrast, a counselor who is in fact the caregiver and acts largely independently is not an adjunct to the psychiatrist and thus is not covered by the privilege.

This dispute arose after the State of Indiana filed a delinquency petition concerning C.P., a sixteen year old girl, alleging habitual disobedience, frequently called incorrigibility. Ind. Code § 31-6-4-1(a)(4) (West Supp.1990). C.P.’s mother was the complaining witness; it was she who executed a consent to disclose confidential information relating to treatment C.P. had received at the Four-County Counseling Center. The trial court appointed an attorney as pauper counsel and guardian ad litem. C.P. denied the incorrigibility charge, and the court held a fact-finding hearing. The State called as a witness Mark Brown, a social worker from the community mental health center. Brown had provided therapy, diagnosis and treatment to C.P. the previous year. C.P. objected to Brown’s testimony, asserting the physician-patient privilege. C.P. also objected to the introduction of her records from the mental health center, raising three grounds: the physician-patient privilege, hearsay, and invalidity of the consent given by C.P.’s mother. The trial court overruled the objections. C.P. requested certification of these questions for interlocutory appeal. The trial court certified the questions concerning admissibility of Brown’s testimony and of the records and stayed its proceedings pending appeal.

The Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s decisions on both evidentiary questions. In the Matter of C.P. (1989), Ind. App., 543 N.E.2d 410. The Court of Appeals’ decision was correct.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.