Louisiana Court of Appeal April 10, 1990, No. 89 CA 0267 (Roe v. State, Division of Administration)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-04-1990
SHORTESS, Judge.
This suit was brought by Ronald J. Roe, doing business as Transcription Unlimited (plaintiff), against the State of Louisiana, Division of Administration (defendant). It asserts that defendant advertised for bids for the furnishing of dictation1 services for Charity Hospital in New Orleans (CHNO); that plaintiff’s was the “lowest, responsible” bid; that defendant improperly sought to cancel the [bid] proposal after the opening of the bids; and that plaintiff is entitled to be awarded the contract. By two amending and supplemental petitions plaintiff alleges damages in the form of loss of profits2 and asserts that the contract entered into for the interim between the date of expiration of the previous year’s contract and the date that a new bid proposal (with revised specifications) resulted in an award which was “contrary to law and regulations.” No damages distinct from the rejection of plaintiff’s bid are alleged as a result of the interim contract, *476and plaintiff does not assert that he should have been awarded a contract for the interim services. In a third supplemental and amending petition, plaintiff names Hugh M. Carleton and Sharilyn Livingston, both employees of the Division of Administration, defendants.
After trial on the merits, the trial court rendered judgment for plaintiff and against defendant for $42,215.25 in lost profits. Defendant appeals, specifying error in the trial court’s determination of improper rejection, in the trial court’s finding that plaintiff should have been awarded the contract, in the award of lost profits, and in the denial of the individual defendant’s peremptory exception of prescription.
CANCELLATION OF THE BID SOLICITATION
A bid solicitation may be rejected “only if it is determined in writing by the chief procurement officer or his designee that such action is taken in the best interests of the state.” LSA-R.S. 39:1599.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit