Louisiana Court of Appeal May 15, 1990, No. 89-KA-0376 (State v. Neumeyer)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-1990

SCHOTT, Chief Judge.

Defendant was convicted of three counts of willfully failing to pay over to the state sales taxes due from a retail business for the months of August, September, and October, 1985, in violation of R.S. 47:1641.

Defendant was the treasurer of a corporation operating a retail food and beverage establishment. She was tried on nine counts of failing to remit sales taxes, one count for each month from April through October, 1985 and March and April, 1987.

A review of the record for errors patent reveals none except in the wording of the indictment which was assigned as an error by defendant and is treated below.

By her first assignment of error, defendant contends that the trial court erred in denying her Motion to Quash the indictment because in each count the word “willfully” is omitted from the description of the offense.

R.S. 47:1641 provides that any person obliged to collect and pay over sales tax and “who willfully fails.... to pay over such tax_” commits the crime. Defendant contends that without the word “willfully” she was not charged with an offense. Defendant requested that the jury be permitted to view the indictment and contends she was prejudiced by the court’s denial of this request.

In the context of a criminal charge “willfully” and “intentionally” have the same connotation. State v. Clark, 242 La. 914, 140 So.2d 1 (1962). See also State v. Vinzant, 200 La. 301, 7 So.2d 917, 922 (1942). In the absence of qualifying provisions in a criminal statute the terms “intent” and “intentional” have reference to “general criminal intent”. R.S. 14:11. In R.S. 47:1641, there are no qualifying provisions for the word “willfully” other than the definition of the crime itself, i.e., the failure to pay over tax which the accused was required to collect from her customers. Since the offense includes only a general criminal intent, the word “willfully” (intentionally) was not required to be included in the indictment. C.Cr.P. art. 472.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.