Louisiana Court of Appeal June 27, 1990, No. 89-126 (Leday v. United Insurance Companies of America)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-06-1990

GUIDRY, Judge.

Decedent, Ezola Leday, purchased two life insurance policies with defendant, United Insurance Company of America (United). The first policy (No. UG1454564) was issued on March 5, 1987 with ultimate benefits of $2,750.00. The second policy (No. UG1460473) was issued on July 1, 1987 with ultimate benefits of $1,500.00. Plaintiff, Enola Leday, was the named beneficiary in both policies. Both of the United policies (hereafter policy) contain the following modified two year death benefit clause in bold print:

“Whole Life — Modified 2 Year Death Benefit — Death Benefit is Premiums Paid Increased at an Annual Rate of 10% During First 2 Years Ultimate Amount Payable for Death After First 2 Years Premiums Payable for Life — Non-Participating”

This language appears in each application and also on each page of the policy. According to the policy’s language, the insured must live for two years beyond the issue date for the beneficiary to receive the *1315ultimate benefits. Ezola Leday died on September 6, 1987, approximately six months after the issuance of the first policy and two months after issuance of the second policy. In accordance with the policy language, United paid to plaintiff the premiums paid by decedent plus ten percent annual interest thereon. Plaintiff sued for $4,250.00, the total amount of ultimate benefits payable under both policies. Defendant filed a motion for summary judgment seeking dismissal of plaintiffs demand. The trial court granted summary judgment in favor of defendant and plaintiff appealed.

The material facts are without dispute. The legal issue presented is whether the clause in United’s policy which provides for a modified death benefit, if the insured dies within two years of the issue date, is valid in Louisiana.

An insurance policy is a contract and the parties may insert any provision or exclusion they desire, so long as the pojicy complies with the Insurance Code and does not violate public policy. Pareti v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.