District Court of Appeal of Florida July 16, 1990, No. 89-1920 (Grimes v. Waters)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-07-1990

WENTWORTH, Judge.

Claimant seeks review of a workers’ compensation order by which various benefits were awarded as payable by the employer. It was further determined that appellee Liberty Mutual Insurance Company is not responsible for such payment, as the employer was not insured by Liberty Mutual on the date of claimant’s accident. Claimant challenges this ruling, asserting that Liberty Mutual should be estopped from denying coverage. We find that the circumstances of this case do not require such an estoppel, and we therefore affirm the order appealed.

Claimant sustained an industrial accident and injury in January 1987, and testified that he signed an incorrect notice of injury form with a later accident date because he was forced to do so by the employer. Claimant stated that the employer had expressed uncertainty as to whether he had any workers' compensation coverage, and required the inaccurate notice so that the accident might be covered by a new policy of insurance. The employer had been insured under both an automobile policy and a workers’ compensation policy with Liberty Mutual, but this coverage was cancelled in the fall of 1986 due to the employer’s nonpayment of premiums. Because of an error in Liberty Mutual’s billing system, the employer received another premium invoice in early 1987. After claimant sustained his industrial injury and pursued medical treatment the employer sent Liberty Mutual a premium check in March 1987. Although the employer wrote his old workers’ compensation policy number on the check, and testified that he had been orally advised that his workers’ compensation premium was due, the record indicates that Liberty Mutual applied the payment to the *236employer’s automobile policy and outstanding arrearages.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.