District Court of Appeal of Florida August 9, 1990, No. 89-192 (Ringhaver Equipment Co. v. Brooks)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-08-1990
W. SHARP, Judge.
Ringhaver Equipment Company appeals from a judgment which held invalid its asserted mechanic’s lien claim against a 42-foot Supersport boat owned by Brooks. The trial judge relied upon stipulations of the parties in the record that Ringhaver was not in privity with Brooks when Rin-ghaver furnished the boat manufacturer (Whitehouse Marine Corporation) with the two diesel engines which were the source of the lien claim; and that when Brooks was notified of Ringhaver’s claim, he no longer owed Whitehouse any monies for the boat. We affirm.
The record discloses that Brooks contracted with Whitehouse Marine to buy a fishing boat for $168,750, which White-house would build and equip pursuant to Brooks’ specifications. Brooks specified an upgrade in engines for the boat: 2 caterpillar diesels. This increased the price of the boat by $15,000.
Whitehouse told Brooks it did not have sufficient credit with Ringhaver (the engine supplier) to obtain the specified caterpillar engines. Brooks then advanced Whitehouse $60,000 on the contract, so that it could buy the engines.
*842Whitehouse entered into negotiations with Ringhaver to buy the engines. Ringhaver agreed to deliver the engines to Whitehouse if Whitehouse obtained letters of credit for the full purchase price, or if it paid 25% down and the balance within 10 days, with a personal guaranty from the owner of the corporation. Whitehouse elected the latter option. Ringhaver did not know the identity of the prospective purchaser from Whitehouse, nor did it make any effort to obtain that information until many weeks later.
Whitehouse paid Ringhaver $10,997.50, and took delivery of the engines, on February 3, 1988. However, Whitehouse never paid Ringhaver the balance owed of $31,-997.50. Whitehouse installed the diesels in the boat.
Because Whitehouse’s work was not progressing to Brooks’ satisfaction, he paid Whitehouse in full on March 25, 1988, and took delivery of the partially completed vessel.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit