Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama March 30, 1990, 8 Div. 426 (Williams v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-03-1990

MeMILLAN, Judge.

■ The appellant was convicted of two counts of robbery in the first degree, in violation of § 13A-8-41, Code of Alabama (1975). He was sentenced to life in the State penitentiary on each charge, the sentences to run consecutively.

I

The appellant argues that the State failed to prove venue as to the offense charged in count II of the indictment. The appellant alleges that the only proof of venue as to this count occurred during the testimony of the victim, who worked at the Circle K store where the robbery in count II occurred, and who stated that the store was “[ljocated in Huntsville.” However, the record indicates that during the victim’s testimony, the prosecutor asked if the store was located in Huntsville, Madison County, and the victim acknowledged that the store was. located in Huntsville. Thus, the State adequately proved venue. “Unless otherwise provided by law, the venue of all public offenses is in the county in which the offense was committed.” Section 15-2-2, Code of Alabama (1975). The victim’s testimony was clear that the offense was committed at a Circle K store located in Madison County.

II

The appellant argues that the trial court erred in limiting his cross-examination of the victim of the offense alleged in count II of the indictment. The record indicates that the witness had already been extensively questioned by defense counsel, during cross-examination, as to the amount of time involved in the offense and the total amount of time during which the victim was able to observe the perpetrator. Thereafter, the following transpired:

“[Defense Counsel]: So on three occasions you observed his face?

“A: Yeah.

“[Defense Counsel]: And each occasion is what, some few seconds?

*356“A: Well, it’s not difficult to do, somebody is coming in the door to your house, or the store, you see them right away.

“[Defense Counsel]: Your best judgment on the total time you looked at his face and studied his face would be probably less than a minute?

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.