Mississippi Supreme Court September 19, 1990, No. 07-CA-59208 (Mississippi State Tax Commission v. One (1) 1984 Black Mercury Grand Marquis)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-09-1990

ROY NOBLE LEE, Chief Justice,

for the Court:

On September 8, 1986, the Mississippi State Tax Commission (Commission) filed an action for forfeiture of a 1984 Black Mercury Marquis, the property of Bettye N. Waggoner (Waggoner), which was seized while being used for transporting intoxicating liquor in a “dry” Newton County, Mississippi. The Newton County Circuit Court, Honorable Edward A. Williamson, presiding, denied the Commission’s motion for summary judgment and granted Waggoner’s motion to dismiss on the ground that the seizure provisions of Miss.Code Ann. § 67-1-17, 1972, as applied to the facts was an unreasonable seizure, and ordered that the vehicle be released to Waggoner. The Commission has appealed to this Court and assigns three issues for consideration here.

FACTS

On August 11, 1986, John Butler, an enforcement agent with the Alcohol-Beverage Control division of the State Tax Commission, observed a liquor store employee in Meridian, Mississippi, loading a large quantity of intoxicating liquor into the trunk of a 1984 Black Mercury Marquis owned by Waggoner. The automobile was registered with a Scott County license plate and Waggoner was a resident of Scott County, where possession and sale of intoxicating liquor was prohibited by law.

When the vehicle left the liquor store, Agent Butler followed it to Interstate 20, thence West on Interstate 20 into Newton County where possession and sale of intoxicating liquor is also prohibited by law, and which county adjoins Scott County on the west. At the point of the Hickory Exit in Newton County, with the assistance of the Sheriff’s Department of Newton County, which had been contacted by radio, Agent Butler and the officers from Newton County stopped the Waggoner automobile.

Although the officers had probable cause to search the automobile, Waggoner granted them permission for the search and the trunk of the vehicle was opened.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.