Louisiana Court of Appeal December 12, 1990, No. 89-745 (Schrader v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Insurance Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-12-1990
FORET, Judge.
Emma S. Schrader instituted this lawsuit against State Farm Fire and Casualty Insurance Company, the homeowners liability insurer of Mary Bayham, for injuries sustained when a ladder she was on fell in Bayham’s home. The jury found that both plaintiff and defendant’s insured were 50% negligent. Both Schrader and State Farm have appealed.
FACTS
Schrader, a guest of her friend, Mary Bayham, gratuitously assisted in the cleaning of the living room and kitchen of the Bayham residence. Those rooms were adjacent and separated only by a bar. A cathedral ceiling transcended both rooms. The floor of the living room was carpeting and that of the kitchen, linoleum or vinyl. A fireplace, chandeliers, and a window of a height of about twenty feet, from floor to ceiling, were in the living room. Another such window was located in the kitchen. To enable Schrader and Bayham to clean those items, as well as the rafters of the ceilings and the walls of those rooms, a stepladder and an extension ladder were used. Schrader was acquainted with the use of these ladders.
Cleaning was to begin in the living room. Before such work was undertaken, Schrader and Bayham tested the stability of the extension ladder: its “rubber feet” were placed onto the floor; the ladder was raised to, and locked in,- an extended position; the ladder was then angled so that its contact with a wall could be made; while Bayham *219held its bottom, Schrader climbed it; and, after Schrader’s descent therefrom, the ladder was lowered to, and locked at, a reduced height. Schrader never requested that Bayham hold the ladder while she was upon it. In fact, after that stability test was conducted, Schrader told Bayham not to hold the ladder because it was solid.
After the ladder had been used about nine times in the living room, Schrader and Bayham moved it to the kitchen, and placed it to the left of the kitchen window, at about the same angle as previously used.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit