Louisiana Court of Appeal December 12, 1990, No. 89-728 (Slaughter v. Guinn)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-12-1990
GUIDRY, Judge.
Plaintiff, Steve Slaughter, d/b/a Steve Motors and Truck Parts, appeals a judgment of the trial court dismissing his suit for damages. We affirm.
We adopt the following recitation of facts as set out by the trial judge in his reasons for judgment:
“This litigation arises out of an auction sale conducted by defendant, GUINN BROTHERS AUCTIONEERS, INCORPORATED (defendant, or Guinn Brothers) in Alexandria on September 17, 1987. Defendant JOHN E. GUINN, president of Guinn Brothers, is a licensed auctioneer and sold the property auctioned on behalf of the corporation.
Although other property was sold at the auction, the major consignor of property was Tidelands Equipment, Inc. The plaintiff, STEVE SLAUGHTER, D/B/A STEVE MOTORS & TRUCK PARTS (plaintiff, or Slaughter) had some 25 items of property for sale at the auction and also purchased three 1983 Chevrolet Kodiak dump trucks for the total sum of $39,750. Only the purchase of the trucks is at issue in this suit.
These trucks were advertised for sale in the advance brochure (P-1) as 1983 Chevrolet Kodiak dump trucks and were also listed in the buyers guide (P-2) as 1983 Chevrolet Kodiak dump trucks (items 104, 105 and 106).
Shortly after the sale plaintiff discovered that the trucks were not 1983 models as advertised and sold, but one was a 1980 model and the other two were 1981 models. Plaintiff had pre-sold the vehicles and the first knowledge he had of a problem was on September 21, 1987, four days after the sale, when representatives of the buyer arrived in Alexandria to pick up the trucks. The next day, September 22, he received the titles in the mail from Guinn Brothers and discovered the discrepancy in the model years.
The evidence shows that there had been no change in the model of Chevrolet Kodiak dump trucks from 1979 to 1988, and, therefore, one could not tell the model year by simply looking at the truck. Slaughter acknowledged that he knew this.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit