Louisiana Court of Appeal December 12, 1990, No. 90-CA-450 (Martin v. East Jefferson General Hospital)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-12-1990
DUFRESNE, Judge.
This is an appeal by Dr. Saeed Ahmed and the Louisiana Patient’s Compensation Fund, defendants-appellants, from an adverse judgment in a medical malpractice action. After a bench trial, the trial judge found that Dr. Ahmed’s treatment of Joyic M. Wells, decedent, fell below the standard of care expected of physicians in his medical specialty, and that this treatment lessened the patient’s chances of survival. He awarded $150,000, to decedent’s mother based on these findings. Because we determine that the judgment resulted from a misapplication of the law, we reverse.
Joyic Wells was twenty-one years old at the time of her death at East Jefferson General Hospital, on November 15, 1980. The immediate cause of death was cardiac arrest due to myocarditis. Both Dr. Ahmed, defendant, and Dr. Preis, a cardiologist called into the case just before Joyic’s death, requested an autopsy, but decedent’s family declined to permit this procedure. At the time of the treatment, as well as at trial, it was Dr. Ahmed’s opinion that the myocarditis was caused by a viral infection, an untreatable condition. Plaintiff alleged that the myocarditis was brought about by undiagnosed systemic lupus er-ythematosus (lupus), and that as a result of Dr. Ahmed’s failure to timely diagnose and treat this condition, decedent lost her chance for survival.
After a medical review panel had unanimously exonerated Dr. Ahmed, the matter came to trial. Dr. Ahmed testified on his own behalf, and also called two internal medicine specialists. All of these doctors agreed that the most probable cause of death was an untreatable viral infection. Plaintiff’s expert, Dr. William McCormack, testified that in his opinion decedent was probably suffering from lupus, and that Dr. Ahmed’s failure to properly test for this condition, or to consult with other specialists, resulted in the decedent losing any chance which she might have had for survival.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit